What's New!!! Headline Feed

About Me

My Photo
Virginia, United States
My name is Lina and I love discussing all things pop culture. I'm also a Ravenclaw, despite what Pottermore says...

Friday, August 26, 2011

Why is the Sorting Ceremony so important on Pottermore?




     So I have been on Pottermore for about 2 weeks now and it has been somewhat of an emotional experience.  It has been emotional because of the sorting ceremony.  You see, I have always fancied myself a Ravenclaw. I thought, “Hey, I’m smart and nerdy, so clearly that is the house I belong in.” I even have a full Ravenclaw uniform.  But in a shocking turn of events I was sorted into…….HUFFLEPUFF??? Me? The house that never has any glory? The house that no one wants to be sorted into because everyone knows that Hufflepuffs are just a “bunch of duffers?” I was so upset that I immediately logged off of Pottermore and went and did something else.  I was disgusted! How dare that sorting hat put me into Hufflepuff. Also I hate yellow!





     But eventually I came to embrace being a Hufflepuff.  I read more about the house and I realized that maybe I really have been a Hufflepuff all along.  This is the least boastful house, so you don’t really hear about how talented the members are.  That makes sense for me because I’m not the boastful type. It’s almost hard for me to talk about anything I may be good at.  This house is also known for being cheerful, hardworking, and believes strongly in fair play.  I would say that those qualities fit me very well.  So, in the end, I realized that not only was Hufflepuff not a bad house to be in, it’s the house that seems to suit me the best. 



     I'm not the only one who had a strong reaction to finding out what house they were sorted into.  It seems that people are taking the sorting results very seriously (since this is the first J.K. Rowling approved sorting quiz) and are shocked to learn which house they actually belong in.  People are stunned because other quizzes have always placed them in Gryffindor, for example, but now they are a Ravenclaw.  Some people have even gone as far as to trade accounts so that they can be in the house they wanted.  But where is this coming from? Why is this whole sorting business such a big deal?




     I think the reason why the sorting has become a big deal is because it’s making people realize who they really are as a person, in a way.  After all, each house corresponds to a basic human trait.  You have Gryffindors who are brave, Slytherins who are cunning, Ravenclaws who are wise, and Hufflepuffs who are loyal.  So when you find out that in reality you are more cunning than loyal, or more wise than brave, it can be a bit heartbreaking.  These books have been out for over 10 years and in that time, fans have all speculated about which house they would be sorted into if the Sorting Hat was real.  They have come to identify with a house for many different reasons.  Maybe their favorite character belonged in that house. Maybe they identified with what that house represented. Maybe they felt that that house was the best one to be in. 




     But then you find out no, you’re not a Slytherin, you’re a Hufflepuff. You’re not a Gryffindor, you’re a Ravenclaw.  That can be very upsetting to find out that basically you are not the person you thought you were.  For me, I always prided myself on my intelligence.  I always did well in school for the most part and I like to learn.  I thought of course I’m a Ravenclaw.  But when I was sorted into Hufflepuff, it was, for me, a big blow to the ego.  I thought, am I not as smart as I thought I was? Luckily my good friend, SilverNettle, talked some sense into me by saying that the quiz was not an IQ test. It’s more of a personality test. So of course I’m still an intelligent person. But, I’m also hardworking and loyal.  Those are not bad qualities to have so I should get over it. And I did. Now I’m a proud Hufflepuff, so you know what it is! Black and yellow, black and yellow, black and yellow, black and yellow!



     I think that in the end people should realize that all of the houses are good in their own ways.  They each have qualities that any person can be proud to have. Whether it’s being brave, cunning, hardworking, or wise.  Not to mention that just because you are sorted into a particular house, it does not mean that you don’t have the qualities of the other houses.  Just because you are in Ravenclaw, it does not mean that you are not also brave. Just because you are in Slytherin it does not mean that you are not also wise.  People are very complicated so most of us probably have all the qualities represented by the houses.  And really, it’s just a silly online game. We should not take these results to heart! 


P.S. SilverNettle, I hope you get Gryffindor! lol 


As always, you can email me at whatsnew@whatsnewlina.com

14 comments:

  1. Dude, spot on.

    This is part of the reason I am so anxious to get my pottermore email - just so I can get sorted! :-P

    ReplyDelete
  2. Haha, you're right. Again xD

    I was so nervous for the sorting test, 'cause I was really afraid that the sorting hat was going to put me in Hufflepuff. The reason I didn't want to get sorted in Huffelpuf was because in the books it always seemed that only left-overs got sorted into Hufflepuff, but also because Hufflepuff doesn't suit me at all.

    But you're right. The house says something about your personality and if you always thought you were a Gryffindor and suddenly the sorting hat puts you in Ravenclaw .. It's like JKR is saying that we don't really know ourselves. It's like Evanna said: Identity crisis, lol XD

    But whatever house you get sorted into, I'm sure that every house has it's good and bad qualities. And I'm sure everyone has something of every house, but it's the quality that we choose that separates us from the rest <3

    Nice blog ^-^

    Ik ben altijd al een Griffoendor fan geweest, omdat mijn lieveling personages in die afdeling zaten. Maar ik pas niet in Griffoendor en ben dus gesorteerd in Zwadderich. Dat neemt niet weg dat ik nog steeds een Griffoendor fan ben <3

    ReplyDelete
  3. For all of you still waiting for your welcome letters--this is absolutely correct. Like Lina, so many of us have a preconceived notion of where we belong...I am so glad that she was able to not freak out and think about her placement logically. As Hogwarts students, we are all much more alike than different. All of us are cunning, loyal, brave, and wise, but sometimes it takes a sorting to realize that we rely on one trait more than others.

    LOVE the rest of the blog by the way...however this post was definitely my favorite!

    --A Slytherin :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great post! It makes me feel a bit better, but stil!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very well put! I also had always thought I was a Ravenclaw, but since Pottermore put me in Slytherin I've come to embrace it :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think this is a very very very appropriate post! I don't know if you saw Alex Carptenter's YouTube video "What if Pottermore sorts me in the wrong house??" My experience is very similar to yours. I got into the books shortly after the 4th one came out (instant love!), when all the online Potterverse world was just coming into being. Of course, there were not the gagillion Sorting Quizes out there, there were only a couple. So I took one... Hufflepuff. At first I was made of by my sister (who OF COURSE got Gryffindor), but I've always been the type to cheer for the underdog, and I was a big fan of Cedric (cried like a BABY when he asked Harry to take his body back.. which incidently, occurred for me, in the back of a classroom where I was covertly reading during a class). I instantly identified with Hufflepuff. Always thought to be weaker than they were, but fiercely loyal and always concerned that equality is upheld. I am always always a stickler for what is right and fair. My high school's motto was VERITAS, and I have never been one to "do whatever it takes no matter what is right or not". When I was little, I considered using the warp zone in Super Mario Bros. as a type of "cheating" and flat out refused to beat the game any way but by going through EVERY SINGLE LEVEL IN ORDER!

    ReplyDelete
  7. When book 5 came out, Tonks was a character I instantly identified with. She was funny, sarcastic, not girly, totally badass, able to see the value in others even if the majority couldn't see it, in love with a werewolf (my husband's very hairy!! LOL!!)... and she changed her hair color on a whim, which is something I'm CONSTANTLY doing... my first greeting by many people is "oh, what color is your hair this week??" You can imagine my absolute ELATION when Jo came out and said that Tonks was a HUFFLEPUFF!! WHOOP!! You can imagine that since 2001, I have taken TONS of Sorting Quizzes... and no lie, every single one HUFFLEPUFF (Quizzes which I ALWAYS answer HONESTLY because that's what's FAIR). So you can imagine my horror when Jo's official quiz put me.........in SLYTHERIN. Freakin SLYTHERIN. I was so nervous when I took the quiz, these questions were so random, and I know I really really overthunk the questions a lot because I wanted to be honest. I was in shock. I was horrified! That's not me! That's not who I am!! Years and years, Hufflepuff is who I've been! I've even been called Tonks by people in the Potter Park in Orlando! And I've had my house identity verified not by my own pick... but over and over again by NUMEROUS quizzes!! Even my 7 year old nephew's talking Sorting Hat that he got at Christmas yelled out "HUFFLEPUFF!" when put on my head!! Then I read the descriptions and such of Slytherin House when I got in Pottermore... Slytherin members are fiercely loyal to their fellow housemates. They're fiercely loyal to their backgrounds and are very proud of their histories. I found out Merlin was a Slytherin. It wasn't sounding all that bad, and then I started looking around my house, my Disney villain snowglobes lined proudly in my living room, next to my Nightmare before Christmas snowglobes... my Disney villain and Nightmare before Christmas shirts and pajama sets packing my closet... characters I loved because I saw them as so multi-dimensional, a little twisted but with such interesting back stories. I looked at my picture of me as the Wicked Witch of the West, who I played in high school. Years before Wicked was published or put on Broadway, I argued with my classmates that maybe she had hard childhood and that she was totally misunderstood and not "evil", and why should Dorothy get her sister's shoes in the first place?? I looked at my bookshelf and my proudly displayed favorite author - Edgar Allan Poe. I realized how proud I am of my own family's geneology, I realize that half my house is a shrine to my Queenship in a New Orleans Carnival organization, and my husband and I's family connection to that club.... and I started realizing.... I'm more Slytherin than I thought. And just like Harry rails against those who would prejudice others because of their background, we get the same prejudice towards those in Slytherin! Yes, some take their family pride WAY too seriously, but pride in your family is not something to be ashamed of, and Slytherin has been just as badly prejudiced against as Deatheaters have prejudiced against others. Like Sirius (who's brother Regulus, a Slytherin, is a silent hero in the series) said, the world is not split into good people and Deatheaters. There's more to all of us than can be confined to only one house, and that we have more in common than we have different. It was a GOOD experience, and I hope that everyone who has been sorted "wrongly" will take the time to make this a positive experience because all of us have a lot to learn about ourselves. And we've got to stop boxing ourselves in and see ourselves in others, even the most unlikely. Now.... for the record... am I going to try again when the site is open to the public? Yes... because I did feel like I second-guessed myself a lot and was way overthinking the quiz... BUT... should I get put in Slytherin again, I am going to OWN IT! ....and immediatley go shopping for more green. :-)

    ReplyDelete
  8. I recognize the "But when I was sorted into Hufflepuff, it was, for me, a big blow to the ego. I thought, am I not as smart as I thought I was?"-part. I felt the same.

    Before I got sorted, I hoped to be a Hufflepuff, because I value their characteristics. But when I actually became one, it was some sort of disillusionment. I identified with Ravenclaw for years, I love their airy common room, the books, blue is my favourite colour...

    It will take a time, but I'll grow accustomed to Hufflepuff as well. I like the Hufflepuff people, and I'm proud to join them. :)

    Yellow is still ugly though.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I agree, and identify hugely. : ) Always felt like a Ravenclaw, sorted into Hufflepuff. Tbh, I still think I’m a pretty solid Ravenpuff, split down the middle. But the pride of the Ravenclaws would probably wear me down; I've always identified myself as being clever, but there are other types of intelligence, and academia (though exciting and valuable, and what I spend most of my time doing) isn’t the most important thing in the world when there’s a lot of crap out there that needs fixing.

    Ultimately, I’ve always identified with Helga Hufflepuff most, out of all the Hogwarts founders. While the others only wanted to accept certain types of students into the school - they were biased, wanting to teach only those most similar to themselves - Helga Hufflepuff wanted to take everyone. Because that’s fair, isn’t it? Everyone has the right to an education, magical or otherwise.

    So, yeah - go Hufflepuff!

    ReplyDelete
  10. (Also, our common room is amazing. If I want books I'll go to the library!)

    ReplyDelete
  11. You're right about the books. I love the library. I'm just not that into the earthy and low-ceilinged thing, I'd better like a room in a tower with big windows. On the other hand... We don't have to walk up so many stairs!

    And I love the bed warmers, I ALWAYS have cold feet. How thoughtful!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Still questioning my Hufflepufflage a bit, but not outright rejecting it anymore. I figure so long as I avoid the plants & sunshine, and keep yellow out of my wardrobe, I'm cool with it. Who said Huffles can't wear black & blue?

    ReplyDelete